Renting out your property comes with decisions that can significantly impact your rental experience, and one of the key considerations is whether to allow pets. While furry friends can make excellent tenants, it’s essential to weigh the pros and cons before opening the door to pet-friendly living.


Expanded Tenant Pool

Allowing pets broadens your potential tenant pool. Many renters have pets, and by welcoming them, you increase your chances of finding responsible and reliable tenants.

Higher Rent Potential

Pet-friendly properties often command higher rents. Tenants with pets are often willing to pay a premium for a home that accommodates their furry family members.

Longer Tenure

Pet owners tend to stay in a rental property for longer durations. The challenges of finding suitable pet-friendly housing encourage stability among tenants with pets.

Responsible Tenants

Pet owners, especially those with long-term pets, are often more responsible. They understand the challenges of finding pet-friendly housing and are motivated to maintain a positive rental history.

Pet Deposits and Fees

You can protect your property by charging pet deposits or fees. This financial arrangement can cover potential damages and provide an additional layer of security.


Property Damage

Pets, especially if not well-trained, can cause damage to the property. This may include scratched floors, chewed furniture, or soiled carpets, leading to additional maintenance costs.

Allergies and Odors

Some tenants may have allergies to pet dander, and lingering odors can be a concern. Even well-groomed pets can leave traces that may impact the property’s appeal to future tenants.

Noise Complaints

Pets, particularly dogs, can be noisy. Barking or other disturbances may lead to complaints from neighbors or violate noise regulations, affecting the overall harmony of the property.

Liability Concerns

Landlords may face liability issues if a pet harms another tenant or causes damage to someone else’s property. This risk increases with certain breeds or if the pet has a history of aggression.

Potential Insurance Implications

Some insurance policies may be affected when allowing pets. Certain breeds may be excluded, or coverage might be contingent on specific conditions, impacting your overall insurance costs.

Ultimately, the decision to allow pets depends on your comfort level, the property’s condition, and local market dynamics. If you choose to welcome pets, establish clear pet policies in your lease agreement, including rules on size, breed, and behavior expectations. Screen potential tenants thoroughly and consider requesting references from previous landlords to assess the pet’s history.


Balancing the pros and cons and establishing clear guidelines will help create a positive experience for both you and your tenants, whether they have two legs or four. Ready to find the perfect tenants or the ideal rental for your needs? Contact CREC Property Management today at (843)-574-9100.